top of page

An Honest Review

A documentation of product efficiency, competency, convenience and durability 

Created and Documented

By Brody C Smith

VS

XP-pen Artist
12 Pro

IMG_0114_edited.png

iPad Air (5th Generation)

Translucent.png

XP-Pen artist 12 Pro

An Honest Review

The XP-Pen artist 12 Pro is a purpose built drawing tablet, created by the company XP-Pen. It is specifically marketed as a cheaper alternative to the very premium end Cintiq by Wacom, whilst maintaining a high level of quality, and still boasting a unique feature set. The workable space of the screen is about 10 inches, with a set of 8 mappable buttons that can be used to access various commands and shortcuts on the windows or mac operating systems. I have found the display to be extremely vivid in colour, with very deep blacks and very bright whites. The expression of colours on the display, however, are so beautiful, that it causes a disparity between this display, and most typical LCD displays. Artworks created on this tablet can have varying hues and brightness levels, depending on the display that the piece is being viewed on, which is inconvenient for ergonomic design. The tablet boasts 8192 levels of pressure sensitivity, which allows for a realistic depiction of art materials  

​

 

this is ugly.png
Translucent.png

The pen that is packaged with the display is very interesting, as, unlike most digital pens, this pen never has to be charged, nor does it require a battery. This makes for a very convenient experience, as the hassle of being required to charge a pen, is one that has deterred me from digital art and drawing tablets, both display and non display, for the longest time. I have, however, noticed a issue when it comes to durability. I have actually had to buy 2 of these pens, because one of them fell off my desk onto the floor, and was completely ruined. The pen became unresponsive entirely, and as such I was un able to use my drawing tablet while I waited for a replacement. This was an enormous inconvenience for me, and an issue that could be solved by increasing the durability of the design by just a little bit. The pen replacement was not too expensive, only running me about $15, but the inability to use my tablet was extremely problematic. Another issue I've noticed with this pen is the mappable buttons. In theory, having buttons on the pen would work really well if you want to quickly use CTRL + Z for example. But in practice it ends up being extremely annoying, and I am constantly accidentally clicking them when re-adjusting my grip. Even after removing and sort of commands from the buttons, I still found myself tapping them, and doing so interrupts the line that I'm trying to draw. ​

 

 

 

Despite some minor transgressions, the XP pen Artist 12 Pro is a wonderfully well executed product. affordable, usable, ergonomic and stylish, it truly ticks all the boxes when it comes to an entry level drawing tablet.

IMG_2790.JPG
Translucent.png

iPad Air (5th Generation)

An Honest Review

Translucent.png

The Apple iPad Air (5th generation) is the 5th generation of the longstanding iPad Air model of the iPad. The iPad Air boasts a beautiful laminated display, making the task of drawing so seamless, it feels like drawing on paper. The display is a gorgeous Liquid Retina display, which is a perfect blend of efficiency, and detail. The device boasts a nine inch workable display area, with a high level of brightness and colour accuracy.  The iPad also has the advantage of running on a native software, rather than requiring an external operating system to leach off like most drawing tablets. iPadOS is fabulously optimized for the iPad and provides a very enjoyable and ergonomically friendly experience. Having the device run an operating system natively as apposed to using an existing one, provides and extra level of portability and ease of function that almost no drawing tablets have ever been able to achieve, and also provides an extra level of versatility, in the fact that because apps are being specifically designed for this device, those applications can take advantage of the specific features that set the iPad apart from other smart tablets and drawing tablets. â€‹

 

IMG_2796.JPG

The apple pencil is weaved into the design of the iPad so well, that it hardly feels like an external piece of hardware. The only issue that I have ever personally experienced, was a difficulty in connecting the device to my tablet. Once I overcame that hurdle, the apple pencil surpassed all of my expectations. The pencil boasts a mappable "double tap" feature, that allows you to double tap the top of the pencils barrel to either change the weight, colour or opacity of the tool that you're currently using. The apple pencil also skimpily snaps onto the top of the iPad Air, and charges wirelessly, making it seem as though it requires no charging whatsoever, and making it much more difficult to lose.

 

 

The iPad Air (5th Generation) is a remarkable tablet that manages to double as a great tool for design, and a useful device for every day use and productivity. The apple pencil fits seamlessly into the design of the pencil 

IMG_2797.JPG
Gray Ipad Air_edited.png
Gray XpPenTablet_edited.png

The XP-Pen artist 12 pro and the iPad air (5th Generation) are both extremely

competent pieces of technology. The XP-Pen Tablet has the advantage of being built from a rationalist perspective, and as such has integral features baked into the hardware, that actively contribute to a better drawing experience. Having physical buttons, as apposed to the gestures of the iPad, is extremely refreshing  and tractile, and makes it feel much more satisfying to undo a mistake. With that said, the process of mapping these commands is a huge hassle, and it commonly resets itself and requires to your redo the inputs manually. The scroll wheel is such an innovative and intelligent integration. Having a physical wheel to scroll in and out with is so fun and makes for a very interactive experience.  

​

The iPad was created from a much more phenomenological perspective, and as such, its features relating to drawing are much more backed into the software itself. With that said, it is extremely well integrated. Having the iPad run its own operating system is so much easier than having to bring another laptop, and a bunch of cords with you every where you go. You can simplify take out the device wherever you go, and start drawing. The fact that the pen requires charging initially seems like an inconvenience, but its battery life is so vast, and the wireless charging is so intuitive and automatic, that I have never had the pencil drop below 80%. Although the display is smaller, the fact that you are able to use your fingers to physically zoom in, and to touch buttons on the screen is a much nicer and less annoying experience than I expected it to be. The requirement to charge the battery of the tablet is not ideal. It lasts between 5-8 hours on full brightness, which is certainly impressive, but it doesn't beat the fact that the XP-Pen tablet never has to be charged at all, as it plugs into an existing device. It is worth noting however that the iPad can also do this with certain Apple Mac devices, and be used as an external monitor, without loosing and charge. Further more, although not physical buttons, there are added buttons down the side of the screen that are used to access various commands that are needed for digital art, much like the artist 12 pro. 

​

Both the Artist 12 Pro and the iPad Air has distinct advantages and disadvantages. Neither of them are objectively better than the other, but I personally find the portability of the iPad air to be so incredibly convenient, that if I had to choose, I would stick by the iPad air. However the XP-Pen tablet is notably much cheaper at $260 with the wireless pen included, whilst the iPad air, when bundled apple pencil (which very notably is not included automatically) is over $1200 AUD. I personally love my iPad air, but the $1000 price difference is not worth the advantages that the device brings, especially when the XP-Pen tablet only barley loses out to the iPad Air, despite being nearly $1000 cheaper. Its worth noting however that the XP-Pen tablet, as aforementioned, does require an external device in order to operate it, but assuming you already have one, the XP-Pen artist 12 pro is an excellent purchase, especially for young artists, looking to expand into the world of digital artworks. The iPad air does have a lot of extra features that cause me to personally prefer it. However if you are only interested in the artistic side of these two products, it would be more wise to invest in a better piece of external hardware for your XP-Pen tablet instead. 

Both of these products are very well designed for their purposes. Even though the XP-pen tablet is less broad in its abilities, it excels at what it was created for. 

​

​

Refferences -

​

Apple. n.d. “IPad Air.” Apple (Australia). https://www.apple.com/au/ipad-air/.

​

“Artist 12 pro Portable Fully Laminated Pen Display | XPPen.” n.d. Www.xp-Pen.com. Accessed April 17, 2024. https://www.xp-pen.com/product/artist-12-pro.html.

An Honest
Comparison

image.png
IMG_2796.JPG
this is ugly.png
bottom of page